claudeb: Just a lonely orange cat watching the moon from the windowsill on a starry night. (critique)

I probably wrote about this before, but if so, it's now lost to time in the depths of my Mastodon feed.

Lately, more and more people have been saying that look, turns out Frank Herbert was right after all. As many surrender their thinking to machines, the men who own those machines are trying to enslave us. Time for a real-world Butlerian Jihad.

The people who say that have a point. But I have a problem with this notion, for at least two reasons:

  1. Frank Herbert loved the word "jihad" a little too much. It doesn't mean what he thought it meant.
  2. Look what he proposed to replace computers with: mentats. That's both creepy and completely misguided. He clearly didn't quite know what computers do.

That was excusable in the 1960s. We can do better now.

But what, exactly? An alternative vision that's no less popular has been that of Sarah Connor in Rambo mode, ready to blow up Terminators. But our SkyNet isn't going to field T-800 units. Its soldiers are going to look more like those Chinese dancing robots: even dumber and uglier than Trade Federation battle droids.

Oh, it could still trigger large-scale nuclear war, but not out of intelligent malice. More likely in response to an operator asking for coffee. Oopsie-daisy!

Our existential threat wears clown makeup. Maybe we should look at a whole other famous book for how to defeat it.

claudeb: A white cat in purple wizard robe and hat, carrying a staff with a pawprint symbol. (Default)
My dream machine is into mecha lately. This time of the retro sci-fi / atompunk variety. Last night I was down the Metro tunnels in a squarish power suit, sussing out a vicious robot about the size of, dunno, a forklift maybe. Luckily, miniguns are quite effective against armor when you can literally run circles around your opponent, as it turned out.

Oh, and it was another of those dreams that start out in third person, then by the end I'm right there in the thick of things.
claudeb: Just a lonely orange cat watching the moon from the windowsill on a starry night. (critique)
Words have a shape. Even in the simplest text editor, you can play with the length of lines and/or paragraphs, if nothing else. You can align, justify and mark up your text. Make it yours.

But markup languages are obsessed with semantics. This is a title. That's a quote. There's a list. A good thing, too, up to a point: knowing what you mean by it. But you can only express what the language allows.

Now pick up pen and paper. All of a sudden a whole new world opens. You can write anywhere on the page. Leave gaps. Write out of order. Break words wherever. You can draw between the lines and write around a drawing. Use different writing implements (not just colors).

Conversely, you can't stretch a sheet of paper; you can only get a bigger one. Oh, it's possible to flip your notebook sideways or use the whole spread, but sooner or later you'll hit the edge and have to turn the page.

A text file on the other hand will go on scrolling for as long as you add to it. You can easily lose track of your own words. Boundaries are useful.

Words are the toy blocks of the mind. We build entire worlds out of these alien geometries that colonized our minds since a few thousand years ago. Did we really invent writing, or did the idea become obvious when its time came, like many others?

Either way, people wouldn't work so hard to make words lose their meaning if words didn't have power. Wield them with courage.
claudeb: Just a lonely orange cat watching the moon from the windowsill on a starry night. (personal)
It took me a long time to accept I probably have ADHD (autism was easier, go figure). For decades prior, I simply thought of myself as lazy and scatterbrained. And you know what? Had to cope somehow anyway. Learned to double- and triple-check that yes, the stove is off. Yes, the door is locked. Yes, the keys are in my pocket. Learned to fight my own brain when this pesky body simply wouldn't bend down to grab that piece of litter from the floor. Gave up my last shreds of mental comfort to do all of the above for two people, because guess what.

I don't know about others. Just saying.

Speaking of which: wish I could spend all day being creature with my online friends, pampered by sci-fi robots. And never mind that's likely not possible with any amount of high tech1. Doesn't it sound creepy?

All I ever accomplished in life was by gritting my teeth and scraping my hands. Call it a tragedy. Call me broken. I literally never saw anything get done in any other way. What am I supposed to do? Pat myself on the head? Life is just behind the corner in clown shoes and boxing gloves. Ha ha.

Corollary: if you can't or won't do the thing for any reason, someone else will have to, or it won't get done. Blame, guilt, judgement, cost: these are details. In other words: you deserve help and support, but someone has to provide it.

Automation is an euphemism for shifting work around while obscuring the trail.

1) No, really: there's growing consensus that tasks like housekeeping and caring for the elderly are too complex, varied and delicate to automate, unless your robot is no longer a robot, but a person. In other words... a personal assistant. One might ask why so many people have to toil for a billionaire instead of being available to help their less fortunate neighbors. The real sci-fi here is imagining a society organized to make that possible.
claudeb: A white cat in purple wizard robe and hat, carrying a staff with a pawprint symbol. (Default)
My dream machine is working well again after a long while. Last night I had the kind of dream where you're watching a movie but you're also sort of there. It was a very loose adaptation of Starship Troopers, except written more like a classic war story. A rag-tag band of soldiers gels into an elite fighting force and goes on to make a difference. Due to budget constraints, most of the action took place at night, and power armor got limited screen time. It was supposed to look xenomorph-like, except angular and metallic. I think not everyone was supposed to have it, either.

Profile

claudeb: A white cat in purple wizard robe and hat, carrying a staff with a pawprint symbol. (Default)
Claude LeChat

Me elsewhere

Newsfeeds

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Page generated 19 Nov 2026 18:41
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios