I probably wrote about this before, but if so, it's now lost to time in the depths of my Mastodon feed.
Lately, more and more people have been saying that look, turns out Frank Herbert was right after all. As many surrender their thinking to machines, the men who own those machines are trying to enslave us. Time for a real-world Butlerian Jihad.
The people who say that have a point. But I have a problem with this notion, for at least two reasons:
- Frank Herbert loved the word "jihad" a little too much. It doesn't mean what he thought it meant.
- Look what he proposed to replace computers with: mentats. That's both creepy and completely misguided. He clearly didn't quite know what computers do.
That was excusable in the 1960s. We can do better now.
But what, exactly? An alternative vision that's no less popular has been that of Sarah Connor in Rambo mode, ready to blow up Terminators. But our SkyNet isn't going to field T-800 units. Its soldiers are going to look more like those Chinese dancing robots: even dumber and uglier than Trade Federation battle droids.
Oh, it could still trigger large-scale nuclear war, but not out of intelligent malice. More likely in response to an operator asking for coffee. Oopsie-daisy!
Our existential threat wears clown makeup. Maybe we should look at a whole other famous book for how to defeat it.